
Andaz San Diego
Best for downtown access, rooftop skyline views, nightlife and meetings/events in the Gaslamp Quarter.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Andaz San Diego is a downtown Gaslamp Quarter hotel with a large rooftop pool, rooftop restaurant (The Rooftop by STK) and an urban nightlife focus; read this if you want skyline views and easy walking access to downtown attractions. Catamaran Resort and Spa is a tropical-style Mission Bay resort near Pacific Beach with beachside dining, water-sport options and a full-service spa; read this if you prefer a bayfront, beach-and-activity resort vibe.
Updated · about 6 miles (≈9.6 km) apart

Best for downtown access, rooftop skyline views, nightlife and meetings/events in the Gaslamp Quarter.

Best for beach-and-bay recreation, on-site water sports and guests who want a full-service spa at a Mission Bay resort.
When Andaz San Diego wins: pick Andaz if you prioritize a central Gaslamp address, rooftop dining and pool access, a 24-hour rooftop fitness center, and event space in downtown walking distance to Petco Park and nightlife.
When Catamaran Resort and Spa wins: choose Catamaran if you want direct access to Mission Bay and Pacific Beach activities (kayaking, sailing, surf lessons nearby), a beachfront restaurant, a full-service spa and larger resort grounds suited to families.
Bottom line: Andaz is a lively downtown hotel centered on its rooftop scene and urban convenience; Catamaran is a larger, bayfront resort geared to beach-and-water-sport recreation and resort-style downtime. Your choice depends on whether you want downtown walking access (Andaz) or bay/beach access and on-site water activities (Catamaran).
| Category | Andaz San Diego | Catamaran Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Urban, lively rooftop-driven hotel in the Gaslamp Quarter | Tropical-style bayfront resort near Mission and Pacific Beaches |
| Location | 600 F Street, Gaslamp Quarter — steps from downtown nightlife, Petco Park and convention center | 3999 Mission Boulevard — on Mission Bay, near Mission and Pacific Beaches |
| Size / Rooms | 159 rooms, including 17 suites | 300 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome (rooftop lounge/pool has 21+ restrictions for non-guests at night) | All ages welcome; family-friendly resort programming and beach activities |
| Pools & beach access | Rooftop pool reserved for overnight guests (shallow throughout); no on-site beach | Outdoor pool and direct bay/beach access; on-site water sports and beach sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | The Rooftop by STK (rooftop restaurant/bar) and STK Steakhouse (lobby-level steakhouse); in-room dining | Oceana Coastal Kitchen (beachfront restaurant), poolside bar and two lounges; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & fitness | No in-house spa; partners with local spas for poolside treatments; 24-hour rooftop fitness center | Full-service spa on site and fitness facilities |
| Water sports & activities | Arranges nearby boat tours and sailing; concierge can book activities | On-site kayaking, motor boating, sailing, windsurfing, waterskiing, snorkeling and surf lessons nearby |
| Event & meeting space | Extensive downtown event space (including a 6,510 sq ft Full Rooftop venue), multiple ballrooms and rooftop venues | Conference center and meeting rooms (listed conference space: 22 sq ft / 2 sq m in supplier listing; has banquet/meeting facilities) |
| Parking | Valet parking only (no self-parking on site) | Self parking and valet parking available (surcharges apply) |
Andaz San Diego sits in the Gaslamp Quarter at 600 F Street, within walking distance of Petco Park, theaters and downtown nightlife.
Choose Andaz for a downtown, walkable stay and rooftop skyline access.
Catamaran Resort and Spa is on Mission Bay near Mission and Pacific Beaches, with beach access and bayfront activities.
Choose Catamaran for immediate bay/beach access and a seaside setting.
Andaz offers 159 rooms, including a range of suites and specialty loft suites in a historic downtown building.
Andaz rooms suit guests who want modern hotel rooms and downtown location with some suite upgrades available.
Catamaran lists about 300 guestrooms, many with garden, bay or beachfront views and multiple studio and suite-type configurations.
Catamaran offers more room variety and bay/beach-view options for families and groups.
Andaz centers food and drink on The Rooftop by STK and STK Steakhouse, with rooftop views and evening programming.
Andaz is for guests who want downtown dining, a rooftop bar scene and nightlife-led outlets.
Catamaran’s dining focuses on Oceana Coastal Kitchen (a beachfront restaurant), plus pool and bar service and 24-hour room service.
Catamaran is for guests who want beachfront meals and casual resort dining after water activities.
Andaz’s signature pool is the rooftop pool and deck used for daytime lounging and rooftop events.
Andaz emphasizes rooftop pool and skyline views rather than beach access or on-site water sports.
Catamaran provides an outdoor pool plus immediate Mission Bay/beach access and a long list of on-site water activity options.
Catamaran is the clear pick if water sports, beach time and bay access are priorities.
Andaz places fitness on the rooftop (24-hour fitness center) and runs evening rooftop entertainment.
Andaz is for guests who want rooftop fitness and downtown nightlife rather than an on-site spa.
Catamaran brings a full-service spa plus family-friendly daytime programming and resort activities.
Catamaran suits travelers seeking on-site spa services and a quieter evening resort atmosphere.

Andaz — rooftop restaurants, downtown bars and walking access to the Gaslamp Quarter.

Catamaran — direct Mission Bay access with on-site kayaking, sailing and beach activities.

Catamaran — full-service spa offering massages and facials on the property.

Andaz — multiple rooftop and ballroom venues including a 6,510 sq ft Full Rooftop for large events.
Catamaran is more family-oriented with beach access and on-site water activities; Andaz welcomes kids but lacks a kids' club and a children's pool.
Andaz sits in the Gaslamp Quarter with rooftop nightlife and two signature restaurants; it's better if you want to walk to bars and downtown dining.
Catamaran operates a full-service spa on site; Andaz does not have an in-house spa but partners with local providers for treatments.
Yes at Catamaran (kayaking, motor boating, sailing and related activities on site). Andaz can arrange nearby boat tours but has no beach access.
Explore how Andaz San Diego stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·